Haunted Places Near Torch Lake: Ghost Stories and Local Legends from Michigan’s Most Mysterious Lake

Torch Lake may be known for its turquoise waters and summer fun, but locals will tell you there’s more beneath the surface — including ghost stories, forgotten foundations, and eerie legends that stretch back generations.

Whether you’re a believer in the supernatural or just love a good spine-tingling tale, these haunted places near Torch Lake might just keep you looking over your shoulder.

👻 The Blue Pelican – Central Lake, MI

Now known as The Blue Pelican, this historic building in Central Lake has worn many faces over the years. Originally built in the early 1900s, it was once called the Torch Lake Inn and served as a boarding house, summer lodge, and even a speakeasy during Prohibition.

But the building’s colorful past has left behind more than just good stories. Over the years, guests and staff have reported flickering lights, unexplained cold spots, and the figure of a woman in white drifting along the second floor — believed to be a former guest who died in the 1920s under suspicious circumstances.

While today it operates as a beloved local restaurant and inn, the stories haven’t stopped. Some say the building still holds onto a few spirits of its own, especially after dark.

🛶 The Phantom Canoe of Torch Lake

For as long as anyone can remember, residents around Torch Lake have passed down stories of a phantom canoe — a silent silhouette seen drifting across the water at dusk or just before sunrise.

No paddling. No sound. Just a dark outline gliding smoothly through the still lake.

Some believe it’s the ghost of an Anishinaabe fisherman, eternally lighting the water with torches. Others think it may be tied to a lost logger or an old mariner who never made it back to shore. While the sightings are rare, they’re consistent — and always a little unsettling.

🪦 Abandoned Foundations Near East Torch Lake

If you hike the woods on the east side of Torch Lake, you might stumble across old stone foundations, forgotten cellar holes, and what looks like the bones of long-abandoned cabins. These ruins date back to the early homesteading days of the 19th century, but the land feels... off.

Hikers have reported strange echoes, sudden chills, and even the sound of children laughing deep in the woods — with no one else around. One popular theory is that a small family once disappeared here during a brutal winter. The official records are vague, but the stories persist.

🕯️ Cemetery Hill – Between Alden and Central Lake

Longtime locals speak in hushed tones about Cemetery Hill, a small and poorly marked burial site hidden somewhere between Alden and Central Lake. Though it’s not on any official maps, those who have visited claim they’ve seen floating lights in the trees — like lanterns swinging in the wind.

Some even describe the scent of pipe smoke or hearing footsteps that stop the moment you turn around. It’s believed to be the final resting place of a few early settlers or lumbermen, though no gravestones remain.

🏚️ The Whispering Cabin (Urban Legend)

A favorite among campfire storytellers, the Whispering Cabin is more legend than documented location. Said to be north of Torch Lake, the cabin is rumored to have been abandoned after a series of family tragedies.

Hikers who claim to have found it say they heard soft murmurs — whispering voices that rise and fall just below the wind. No one’s ever confirmed its exact location, and some locals think the whole thing is myth. Still, that hasn’t stopped curious adventurers from trying to find it.

Truth, Tales, and Torchlight

Whether you believe in the paranormal or simply enjoy a good ghost story, there’s no denying that Torch Lake holds more than just scenic beauty. Its deep history, misty woods, and silent waters provide the perfect backdrop for tales of the unexplained.

So the next time you're boating under moonlight or walking the wooded shoreline at dusk, remember — some stories aren’t just told, they’re felt.

Want to Learn More?

Explore the History of Torch Lake to uncover the lake’s Indigenous roots, glacial past, and how it became one of Michigan’s most iconic destinations.

‍